With no disrespect to those in this thread who've identified good places to eat along I-57, I think we should be honest in admitting that the thoroughness (though not quality) of LTH's recommendations must naturally decrease with increasing distance from Chicago -- aside from nearby cities such as Indianapolis, Milwaukee, Madison, and even Champaign, for all of which I think LTH provides a lot of good information.
What caught my eye, seeing this thread resurface, was boudreaulicious's post from July that indicated that boudreaulicous had gleaned from this thread that the best dining options in Bourbonnais were Jimmy Jo's and Monical's. I lived downstate for nearly 15 years, and I don't know Jimmy Jo's, but I do know Monical's. Not to diss it, it's good pizza (they don't serve alcohol, by the way, if that matters to you after a day of traveling). But it's not the first- or second-best place in Bourbonnais or most other towns where there's a Monical's by any means. A little googling around suggests to me that Koi Asian Bistro (sushi), Chicago Dough Company (pizza), and Flight 102 Wine Bar (small plates) are much better options in Bourbonnais. I imagine there are towns downstate where Monical's is the best option, but they're pretty small towns.
I thought I'd mention this because, although I'm deeply skeptical and suspicous of Yelp, I think there's more objective value to restaurant reviews on Trip Advisor, for example, and I think we should be realistic about how much or how little LTH can tell you about dining options in the Midwest, for example, away from Chicago and other large cities, and we should be open to searching other sites for information about such places, checking out those places, and commenting about them here.
"Your swimming suit matches your eyes, you hold your nose before diving, loving you has made me bananas!"