Thank you C2. I’ve been wanting to comment on the Barrington Heinen’s since first reading the OP’s comments.
I’ve been shopping at the Barrington Heinen’s for about one year and I find it excellent on many levels, including service. Yes, it is pricy, and I tend to shop there for specialty or sale items announced by their emails. But in short, in terms of breadth of selection and quality, it is difficult to find better meat, fish, dairy, produce, deli, prepared or packaged foods. Plus, their wine selection is broad and they offer deep discounts on a rolling basis.
The question at hand, however, is service. I would rate it above par from the beginning, and continuing thru my most recent visit earlier last weekend. Yes, there was a flourish of attention at the beginning of their run here, but that settled into a very pleasant, consistent shopping experience and all queries have been given full, enthusiastic attention.
I should mention that we by no means do the bulk of our food shopping at Heinen’s. We in this area have become spoilt by the recent (past 5 - 7 year) proliferation of food shopping options. Within 20 minutes we can access any of the following: The Fresh Market, Mariano’s, Garden Fresh Market, Joe Caputo’s, Sunset Foods, Aldi, Joseph’s (Crystal Lake), Costco, Orchid Prime Meats (Lake Zurich), Whole Foods, Tres Amiga’s (Wauconda), Gordon Food Service, two WalMart Super Centers and four Jewels.
We shop regularly at Heinen’s for specific items. Here are some we most enjoy.
Fish - specifically, when on sale. Last Saturday they held a one-day sale on Yellow Fin Tuna flown in overnight from Boston, at $5 off normal price (final cost $16/lb IIRC). I cooked a hand-cut 2” thick steak sous vide to 108°F then seared over charcoal. Simply amazing. Last season at a similar sale we bought 6 hand-cut swordfish steaks, froze and individually vacuum sealed, and enjoyed them thru the winter. (I’m a great fan of Boston Fish Market, but they are an hour each way w/o traffic)
Meat - ground fresh daily beef, veal and pork combo for meatloaf. Aged NY strip steaks. Beef short ribs.
Heinen’s ‘Vanilla Bean’ ice cream (now a must have item in our home).
Basques 100% hardwood sugar maple charcoal, 17.6 lbs, product of Canada. Has the most wonderful mildly sweet aroma of any charcoal I’ve ever used. I load up when on sale at $13/bag.
Fresh herbs, when in season from local providers.
Colteryahn Dairy Buttermilk - it tastes and has the texture of the buttermilk our family drank in the 1950’s (Mother was a Nebraska farm girl). I was so surprised and pleased to find this. We make salad dressings and cook with it as well.
There is one glaring downside - driving out of the parking lot on to Rt 59 northbound. Heinen’s provides a police officer during rush hour, but at all other times, due to the insane traffic on that stretch of road, exiting is a risky move.
I guess we can say that in the past year Heinen’s has become a welcome regular stop in our shopping routine.