Thanks, all, for the input…we had a great trip, which ended up considerably more beach lounging than food seeking, but were able to put quite a bit of info to use nonetheless.
Four best foodstuffs of the trip for me (in no particular order):
1) Macarons at
Le Macaron in St. Armand’s circle…wow, these were some phenomenal cookies, a gentle Frenchman so enthused when our oldest boy picked out the mint that he walked out front to show us the herb pot where he grows it and lament the artificial flavor so many Americans call mint. We probably tried 10 flavors, I really enjoyed the lemon too, and the ginger chocolate…and the regular chocolate…and…the flavors were just all so true. The cookies definitely have a short shelf life for peak form, but man, at peak, they are amazing. The one "if you're close, go" place of the whole trip.
2) Caldo Gallego at the
Columbia Restaurant (also St. Armand’s Circle)…could find no fault in this bean soup, an absolute delight
3) Sticky buns at
Ginny and Jane E.’s (at the Old IGA) on Anna Maria…this place was just a few blocks from our house, and I wish I’d gone earlier in the week…a cute place all around, mix of café and flea market and Internet café….sticky buns were perfectly moist, sweet, sticky, and delicious
4) Grouper at the big, loud, touristy
Bahama Breeze in Tampa…a convenient stop near the airport our one night in Tampa. Very much a scene type place, but they served a very nice piece of fish…somehow managed to be the only grouper I ordered on the trip, so this isn’t necessarily meant to exalt their offering over any number of others, but it was quite good.
More details…
We hit Ybor City straight from the airport. I chose poorly. We wanted beer not coffee, and I think after our travels that Carmine’s (which we walked past) or Columbia would have been a more comfortable place to start the vacation. It was after the lunch hour, so the bustle of
Tropicana had worn off. The Cuban was good, I enjoyed my Devil Crab. Garbanzo bean soup I thought was just okay. But the external elements (Styrofoam bowls and plastic spoons, charmless waitress who vacuumed and sprayed cleaning chemicals through most of the meal, empty room) were the wrong pick for the moment…my bad on that. I can definitely appreciate how it would succeed on other terms.
Columbia in Armand Circle had all the class that you’d expect in a classic institution. My soup was just perfect, the yellow rice was very good, the Cuban was excellent. The 1905 salad is really enjoyable as well. I preferred the salteado beef to the marinated pork loin and the yellow rice to the white. Any institution like this, people seem to criticize for not being what it once was. Taken for what it is, I don’t see how you wouldn’t be happy here…I look forward to a return trip.
Our plans for a nice dinner out were derailed by a busy schedule, Beach Bistro was sorely tempting, and my in-laws rarely make a trip that way without heading to the aforementioned Dry Dock on Longboat Key. I would love to have had the chance.
And on our way back to the airport, Ted Peter’s and Mazzaro’s.
Ted Peter’s….maybe my expectations were too high. Maybe I really screwed up by not ordering the mullet. I don’t know. The place oozes character, and was certainly worth a stop on that alone. I was a little wary of the smoked salmon plate right on the Gulf, but hey, when you have 3 smoked fish (mackerel was out), they all ought to be good, right? And the ladies like smoked salmon. It was okay, but a bit dry and chewy and fishy. Not bad at all but nothing revelatory, and not even particularly good. The fish spread…I tried to order the sandwich, but the lady suggested a big bowl would be better for splitting. Wasn’t real popular. It was like tuna salad, and I think I would have liked the sandwich; scooped onto soda crackers, it was fine but not exciting to me.
I did really enjoy their potato salad, with big bacony chunks. And the key lime pie, nice crumbly crust, great limey flavor, disappointing whipped cream from a can, but overall, a nice slice. Best two or three in the world? Don’t know about that.
Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives stopped at a BBQ joint about a 5-minute walk from our house, RJs, which has received some attention here. It’s a great little place, good food, decent ‘que, people who care, live music…I like it a lot. But if some out-of-towner visiting KC saw it on TV and made it a must-visit stop, representative of KC cuisine, well, I don’t think they’d be getting a great pic. That’s a little how I felt about Ted Peter’s. Though the smoking set-up is really something to behold—I’ve never seen anything quite like it. Don’t get me wrong, I’m really glad to have gone. Just wasn’t too impressed by the food.
Mazzaro’s, I wasn’t too hungry after salmon, fish spread, potato salad, and pie. But man, what a cool store. The place was packed, absolutely slammed on a Saturday mid-afternoon. I don’t know what kind of margins the place runs on, but the sandwich pictures posted earlier don’t really do justice to the size of these $5 monsters. Jared would be crying for his mama if faced with one of these footlongs. They may be a foot in circumference too. Definitely worth a stop…I wish we had gone on the way down to stock up for our eating in nights on the island.
Some other stops…
Tortilla Bay (Anna Maria) was a forgettable Southwestern/Mex-type place. Not bad by any stretch, though, decent option.
Hurricane Hank’s (Anna Maria) is a local island joint, everyone but me got the fried grouper sandwich, and based on my few bites, it was terrific. My fish special of the day (don’t recall the name) was fine, but I wish I’d ordered the grouper.
Rod and Reel (Anna Maria) the pier just north of the aforementioned City Pier restaurant. Had a fine diner breakfast there one morning in a terrific setting.
The Waterfront, a little bit nicer joint, just across from City Pier. Really an outstanding beer list, and a terrific looking menu. Friendly crowd, good staff, the food was hit and miss, maybe more towards the miss. I don’t even recall my order…I know my father-in-law was incredibly pleased with his lamb chops, and he orders a lot of lamb chops.
Gator’s Dockside (northeast Tampa) is a local chain with maybe 20 restaurants. Burgers and chicken tenders and things. We did get an appetizer of gator tails, which the kids thoroughly enjoyed, and hey, if you’re going to be feeding the kids chicken tenders, they may as well be made of alligator.
Le Macaron
382 Saint Armands Circle
Sarasota, FL 34236-1313
(941) 552-8872
Ginny & Jane E's
9807 Gulf Drive
Anna Maria, FL 34216
(941) 778-3170
http://www.annamariacafe.comBahama Breeze
3045 North Rocky Point Drive
Tampa, FL 33607
(813) 289-7922
http://www.bahamabreeze.comGators Dockside
(many other locations also)
5840 East Fowler Avenue
Tampa, FL 33617-2312
(813) 341-4445
http://www.gatorsdockside.comTortilla Bay Southwest Grille
5318 Marina Drive
Holmes Beach, FL 34217
(941) 778-3663
http://tortilla-bay.comHurricane Hank's
5346 Gulf Drive
Holmes Beach, FL 34217-1766
(941) 778-5788
The Waterfront Restaurant
111 South Bay Boulevard
Anna Maria, FL 34216
(941) 778-1515
http://www.thewaterfrontrestaurant.netRod & Reel Pier Restaurant
875 N Shore Dr
Anna Maria, Florida 34216
(941) 778-1885