Last stop of the trip was in Kapadokya (Cappadocia).
Pictured: Houses carved out of the landforms

Unlike Antalya where it was possible to get away from the tourist traps, Kapadokya is a very tourist-focused region, with good reason since the sights are really unique and interesting. However to get great Turkish food you have to get out of Kapadokya to either of the nearby cities Nevşehir or Kayseri. Nonetheless we did the best we could in the region, though we did make it out for a couple meals.
Nazar Börek, GöremePictured: Sosyete börek with spinach and feta

Sosyete börek is made by rolling the stuffing in fresh phyllo dough so it comes out more doughy and less crispy. Nazar Börek does a nice rendition that highlights the textural contrast between the outer layer and the chewy insides. The place is run by a nice, elderly couple who sit in front of the restaurant hailing guests and munching on pistachio nuts. The mezes and gözlemes were bland and uninteresting, but the börek wasn't half bad.
Couldn't find an address, but it's on the one road in town.
Ziggy's Cafe, ÜrgüpPictured: Meze assortment

Ziggy's was written up in the New York Times and it has a huge number of positive reviews on Trip Advisor, so we figured we'd give it a shot. It's a nice space with luxurious seating and a very cozy feel. They don't have a selection of meze to choose from, instead you order the meze platter which comes with an assortment of meze made with what's in season. The meze definitely featured fresh ingredients, but for the most part they tasted safe and uninteresting. After the meze came the entrees which were western style meats. The steak was topped with a strange tomato sauce that couldn't be further from Turkish cuisine and the chicken, while skewered like a kebab, had almost no spice or char. Also, Ziggy's was the only time on the entire trip that I was startled by how expensive the food was. I understand why people like it, but it wasn't for us.
http://www.ziggycafe.com/Dayı'nın Yeri, AvanosPictured: Kaşarlı Pide

Avanos is fun little town that is famous for its pottery (and store owners who call you off the street to watch a pottery demonstration). I was surprised to see so many little restaurants selling Turkish specialties like işkembe çorbası (tripe soup), kelle (sheep's head), and paça çorbası (trotters soup). Sadly, they were all closed the day we visited, so we didn't get to try any, but if I were ever back in the area, my first stop for a mid-day meal would be Avanos. Nonetheless, we had a recommendation from our hotel owner for a kebab shop in the middle of town.
When we walked in we could smell the coals and the grilled lamb coming from the large grill in the middle of the room, a very very good sign. The waiter recommended we try one of their pides so we got one with ground meat and kashkeval cheese (kaşar peyniri). The pide had excellent char on the bread and the cheese was nice and gooey. Afterward we ordered a couple kebabs that were being cooked on the grill in the middle of the room. Nice char, lots of spices, good kebabs all around. From our limited experience, Avanos seemed like the place to get food in the area. Too bad we discovered it on our last day.
http://www.dayininyeri.com.tr/AnaSayfa-EN.aspxIhlara ValleyPictured: Small shop specializing in gözleme

Pictured: Stock footage of gözleme being made

If you're taking a trip to Kapadokya, you're likely to take a hike through the Ihlara Valley. As we were hiking through the valley we saw a little shop built on top of the river. Naturally our expectations were low, but we were hungry and could use a break, so we found a seat at one of the tables surrounded by the river and ordered some tea and gözleme. Gözleme is made from a thin dough that is stuffed with cheese or meat and cooked on a griddle, similar to a quesadilla. There are gözleme shops all along the highways where you can stop and watch an old Turkish lady roll out the dough and cook it on a traditional rounded griddle. Surprisingly the gözleme we had in Ihlara Valley was very good. The dough was rolled thin so it was crispy and the cheese was just right. Avoid gözleme that has been premade and reheated. It's not hard to find gözleme that is rolled to order, apparently you can even get good gözleme on a hiking trail in the middle of nowhere.
The capital of the region is a small city called Nevşehir. There's not much to see in the city itself, but after two nights in the heart of Kapadokya we decided to head into the city to do some shopping and get away from all the tourists.
In the center of town is a large shopping complex called the Kapadokya Forum, complete with a movie theater, a Gap, and a food court. After a couple hours of walking around in the shopping center we headed up to the food court for dinner. They have some typical western options like McDonald's and Pizza Hut, but our eyes immediately gravitated towards the kebab shop in the corner.
TNR İskenderPictured: İskender Kebabı

It's a surprisingly nice restaurant for a food court with lots of tables and good service. The place was packed and they were pumping out plate after plate of İskender. The dish is named after its creator (the name is a form of the name Alexander) who owned a famous kebab shop in Bursa in the late 19th century. A great İskender kebab will have thinly shaved slices of meat, each well browned, on top of fresh pita bread, covered in hot tomato sauce and sizzling butter served at the table, with a side of thick yogurt. If you only eat one kebab in Turkey, this is the one to get. Lots of places offer this dish, but be sure to go to a place that specializes in İskender, it makes a big difference. TNR nailed it on all fronts.
I couldn't find the address of the shopping mall, but it's called Kapadokya Forum. It's the biggest mall in town.
MadoPictured: Baklava assortment and orchid root ice cream

After the great kebabs in the mall we were on the look out for dessert. The dessert shops in the food court didn't look that appetizing so we decided to try our luck looking around town. Across the street from the mall, in a BP gas station, is a Mado. Jackpot! This gas station version of Mado had much less ambiance than other Mados, but the desserts were every bit as good. We ordered a mix plate of baklavas and a nice thick slice of maraş dondurma, Mado's speciality. The baklavas are top notch, but my absolute favorite are the green ones that are made with thinner dough and stuffed with tons of pistachio nuts. Maraş dondurma (hence the name Mado) is made from orchid root so its much thicker and stretchy. It has a pleasant, though mild flavor, but the texture is wonderful, particularly when paired with crunchy, nutty baklavas. You can find maraş dondurma in tourist areas being served by guys performing tricks with the thick ice cream. Be careful, they don't just play tricks with the ice cream, more than once they tried to overcharge me or give me two when I asked for one. Plus the ice cream from those types of places isn't as good. For the real deal, head to Mado (or better yet Kahramanmaraş province where orchid root is the local delicacy).
Üstad Necip Fazıl Kısakürek Bulvarı No:23
Nevşehir (in the BP station)
Nevşehir is a nice escape from the tourist crush in Kapadokya, but for a top notch Turkish experience, Kayseri is the spot. Most people fly in and out of Kayseri on their way to Kapadokya, but many ignore it. It's about an hour from Kayseri to the main tourist cities of Göreme and Ürgüp, so it's not realistic to stay there, but definitely leave time before or after (or both as we did) to sample some of the local cuisine.
Pictured: Butcher shop in Kayseri

As soon as you get into downtown, you can tell that Kayseri is known throughout Turkey for its butcher shops. Hanging in the window are all kinds of pastırma, air-cured meat, and sucuk, spicy sausage. You can smell the wonderfully spicy, funky meat from down the street. We bought some pastırma as a gift for some family and the entire bag smelled for weeks afterward. This is potent stuff.
Pictured: Ekmek Kadayıfı

The region is also famous for the quality of its wheat. All over town are shops making sandwiches in dürüm wraps and the most famous local specialty is mantı. As we were walking down main street we saw a dessert shop with huge trays of ekmek kadayıfı which is a dessert made with bread cooked in syrup. It's made with a particularly spongy bread that soaks up the syrup and gets chewy on the bottom where it caramelizes (the best part of course). Traditionally it is topped with clotted cream.
Kaşık-laPictured: Entrance

Kaşık-la is perhaps the most famous spot in Kayseri for mantı. The name means "with a spoon" which is how they recommend you eat the mantı. It was remarkably easy to find because it's located next to a Toyota dealership. And by next to I mean they share a building and the parking lot is filled with new cars. When you walk in they have pictures of all their specialties hanging on the wall, which makes it pretty easy to order.
Pictured: Mantı

We ordered a bunch of different dishes from their yöresel menu which means local specialties, and everything was great, but the mantı really stood out above the rest. Kayseri style mantı is made with a thicker dough so that's it's still chewy after it's boiled. While mantı is always served with garlic yogurt, Kaşık-la went one step further bringing a side of crushed garlic so you can make it as garlicky as you want. We liked it so much we came back our last day in town to get another bowl of that mantı.
Pictured: Kiremitte Pastırma

Our second trip was in the morning, so I had to order a classic breakfast dish, pastırma cooked in a clay bowl topped with a runny egg. Oh man. The pastırma is seriously spicy, I could taste it for the rest of the day. When baked in the clay bowl the edges get crispy and the aroma becomes even more intense. This is a pastırma lovers paradise.
Kaşık-la
Zafer Caddesi No: 4
Kayseri
http://www.kasikla.com/