WillG wrote:I have a question concerning the economics of CSA's. I am doing the Sandhill farms in Grayslake CSA share, and the cost comes to around $32 per week. I have only received 1 week so far so I cant really comment on the quality, though that 1 week was very good. My concern is the quantity. I thought that the idea behind CSA's was that we prepay, and then share in the harvest. If the weather is bad, we might not get much, but in a decent year we should get good value for our investment. The portion that i received looked similar to what is pictured in this thread, and I don't expect any more in the prime of the harvest because they use the same size box all year round. I think that I could go to the farmers market and buy this amount for less than the $32 I am spending per week. I was expecting to get a lot more produce from the CSA. I thought that I was running the risk that 1 week in might be 25 pounds of spinach, but that barring a drought I would get a lot to cook with. Instead it looks like lots of fairly small portions (at least for a family of 5) of a large variety of things.....sort of like I went shopping at a higher quality, more variety Whole Foods. This is the opposite of what I was expecting.
Were my expectations unrealistic, or has something in the CSA world changed?
Thanks, Will
I've made this point before, but I believe it is worth making again. I am, like you, somewhat hazy on whether a CSA is a "good buy". To me, however, the ancillary benefits of the CSA make up for whatever shortfall may exist in the per week price.
The biggest advantage of subscribing to a summer or "main" season CSA is that you then get on track to participate in other season CSAs, spring and fall. These CSAs are much more limited, but if you want to maintain your supply of local food or jump start the season, they are crucial. Most CSAs with other season programs either restrict subscriptions to existing members or give priority to existing members.
The next reason for a membership, I believe, is the contact and relationship with the farmer. Me, I relish the chance each year to visit Farmer Vicki's farm. This year we learned a lot about her new organic fertilizer program and saw her expanded poultry operations. If the day was not good enough, I got to bring home a door prize of about 50 freshly picked zucchini flowers. A CSA membership gives you the chance to be part of the farm.
Being part of the farm has other advantages. Somewhat to my wife's chagrin (who hates when I mess with other people's business, always bringing up Jerry Seinfeld's ill-fated efforts to help Baboo), I've helped talk Vicki into a fall crop of iceberg lettuce. That kinda line to the farmer comes from CSA-ship.
I think it also goes without saying, as this thread has shown, that being in a CSA forces you to eat more than you might, but this is a good thing too. It ties you into your local food 'cause you already have it and paid for it, and it forces you to eat stuff, say collard greens, that you may not have tried.
So yeah, on a purely cost basis, I think there are issues, but overall, I think other benefits of the CSA overcome those issues.
Think Yiddish, Dress British - Advice of Evil Ronnie to me.