Passover/Mexican Coke Taste Test 2008
The Contenders
On the left, weighing in at 12 oz. and 140 calories; wearing the red and white aluminum suit...Kosher for Passover Coke.
On the right, also weighing in at a svelte 12 oz. and 150 calories; wearing the fashionable red, white and clear glass bottle is the challenger from south of the border....Mexican Coke. Let's give 'em both a big round of applause!
The Tale of the Tape
This scrappy contender, originally hailing from the Land of Israel boasts sucrose as it's sweetener, eschewing it's normal HFCS for Passover. He doesn't fight very often, but makes an appearance every year at this time to the delight of his fans.
This hard working contender from the land of tacos and big thirst pulls no punches, boasting pure sugar as it's sweetener. Normally, Mexican Coke quietly goes about its business in the Hispanic community, hoping to divert attention from itself due to his questionable legal status, but today he's stepping out of the shadows to take on his only rival in this country.
The Rules of the Contest
Identical plastic cups were filled and secretly marked by the referee (The Chow Poodle) and then brought into the tasting chamber and placed on a table. The identity of the contenders was kept secret from the taste testing panel (me). The panel of judges (me again) first sniffed the bouquet, noted the amount of carbonation in the glasses, then tasted both cups repeatedly.
The Results
The results were interesting. Passover Coke seemed to have more of a bouquet of cloves than Mexican Coke. Passover also seemed to have a bit more carbonation. I wrote this off as being the difference between traveling all the way from Mexico to compete VS. Passover only having to come from the local bottling plant. Mexican Coke seemed a bit sweeter, with Passover being zippier with more carbonation. Not surprisingly, the taste of the drinks was nearly identical, with any perceived differences a matter of splitting hairs.
The judge declared a draw, with points going to Passover for clean crisp carbonation, but points going to Mexican for a fuller taste and the (preferable to me) glass bottle.
The lingering question here is, what (if anything) is the difference between listing sucrose as the sweetener and listing sugar as the sweetener? I'm sure someone can shed some light on this (are you listening Ronnie Suburban?)
Steve Z.
“Only the pure in heart can make a good soup.”
― Ludwig van Beethoven