If, and I stress the "if," JCF and Janet Franz are one and the same, then I find her post irresponsible. Her own Trib colleague, Bill Daley, explicitly identified himself and his affiliation when he
posted here seeking stories. That is right and it is proper. Seeking information or stories from sources--and that's what we are here, folks--without identifying yourself as a journalist is wrong. Period.
Lest I be mistaken in jumping on my high horse, I consulted the Lovely Dining Companion, a reporter for over a decade at one of the largest newspapers in the US before moving to Chicago. She concurred without hesitation.
If Franz is JCF, she owes us disclosure. I am NOT suggesting that she violated any confidences in her "whine" (at least none to my knowledge) but only that she has an explicit obligation when she posts here, on Chowhound, eGullet, or any like board expressly seeking stories, to clearly and completely identify herself. To imply by omission that she is simply a private person who is interested in "stories" without disclosing that she is, in fact, a reporter for a major daily newspaper in the market concerned, is misleading and wrong. And I'd bet that her editors would agree.
PS For what it's worth, Franz is not listed as a member of the Tribune staff on the paper's
website. Assuming that the webpage is completely current and accurate, that suggests that Franz is a stringer of some sort. But does not in the least alter her responsibility or obligation.
Gypsy Boy
"I am not a glutton--I am an explorer of food." (Erma Bombeck)