Diane wrote:I think you may have had an off night.....
I think I might have hit two off nights...
I've now been to Anteprima twice and...shrug...
This place just doesn't do it for me.
The first visit I went with two friends who love this place (both fabulous cooks and I really trust them), plus I knew it had gotten some LTH love.
I tried the rabbit, which was delicious, but everything else (mixed appetizers, a fish dish, the orrechiette with house-made lamb sausage) was pretty bland. In fact, we all agreed that the fish tasted a little off. My friends urged me to try it again so I went last night with another friend. Also, it's a cute little place and it's close to where I live.
The host was very warm, we got to our table right away (and they were busy).
But the waiter kind of rubbed me the wrong way--he just didn't seem very interested in helping us, though I wouldn't say service was bad (indifferent, maybe).
Because I didn't like what I tried the first time, I wanted to make sure we hit the highlights. So I asked, something like, "Could you give us a recommendations for what you think are the highlights of the menu in the starter section?". He sort of shrugged, pointed at the specials pages (a list of 10+) items and said "Try the specials, everything there is seasonal"
Really? Seasonal items on the specials list?
The bread was good but not great.
We did really enjoy the selection of wines by the 1/4 liter (an aglianico and a primitivo)
We tried a corn sfumato (not sure about the spelling, basically a tart/pudding type of deal) which was very good, stuffed zucchini blossoms with ricotta which were kind of bland, corn and crab risotto (no taste of crab at all, undercooked risotto and pretty bland) and the eggplant ravioli (wish I'd read happy stomach's review they were rubbery and also not much flavor. After the appetizers, we decided to make it a light meal (no entrees or dessert) and hit Pasticceria Natalina. Dinner for two included 2 appetizers, 1 full pasta, 1 half pasta and 2 1/4 L of wine for $75 (so not expensive but certainly not cheap).
Alas, I'd forgotten they P.N. is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. So we hit Baskin-Robbins for some peanut butter and chocolate ice cream, which turned out to be the highlight of the night.
I really like the idea of Anteprima but I'm still searching for a go-to neighborhood Italian place. This isn't it for me.