In our first round we awarded the prize to two places which do ground-breaking, mind-expanding and cliche-busting Thai food, Spoon and TAC Quick. Given the amount of discussion and championing they've enjoyed here (and in our past lives on Chowhound), it would have been a serious oversight not to honor them in the first round as quintessential GNR choices.
Elephant Thai is of a different order to me, but equally worthy-- for the reasons that we say "neighborhood" in the award title. Elephant Thai not only introduced Thai food to a neighborhood where it hadn't existed before, showing how ethnic foods can break out of their enclaves or Hipster Central and win converts even in neighborhoods where the crowd tends to be older and probably a bit conservative in its tastes, but it has all the other virtues of a superior neighborhood joint-- high quality food, a specials board that shows some ambition and gently works to expand the horizons of its customer base, and personable owners who recognize customers by name (or at least dishes) and will even share what they've made for lunch.
I just ate, purely because of where I happened to be around lunchtime, at a place that won an award from another, wood-pulp-based source--
Tom Yum Thai. I could see that they were trying to do a better job with the Amerithai standards than the average place, and everything was very fresh-- but the result was neither fish nor fowl, neither Amerithai-flavored enough (too little sugar and soy sauce), nor Thai-flavored enough (too little fish sauce or chili).
In that case I suspect a neighborhood that was desperate for Thai has gone overboard in its enthusiasm for a restaurant that rises only ever so slightly above average, and in some ways is sort of ill-served by what ambition it does have (if you're going to make Amerithai, then by gum sell out and make sugary, salty Amerithai, don't make watered-down Amerithai). The balance of all these factors was not there in the food. Elephant Thai is, to my mind, the place that has balanced them extremely well; there was room for
any Thai restaurant in Edgebrook and luckily they got one with a sure hand and a commitment to real, pleasing flavors.