Katie wrote:I've really enjoyed the episodes I've seen so far of "I'll Have What Phil's Having." Not really a cooking show; it's a food-centered travel show.
That's exactly right, Katie. Phil Rosenthal's premise is good, the camerawork is really, really nice, but boy, I sure would like to see more substance. His constant wide-eyed 'best-I-ever-ate' countenance is somewhat cloying and borderline distracting. And the problem is, that idiosyncrasy of his is getting more prominent. He kept it in check more or less in Tokyo for his debut episode, Florence was pretty much over the top, and last night's Paris was Phil simply being out-and-out weird. As I said, the production work absolutely saves the show for him.
At least Bourdain or Zimmern (especially now that he's gone off the bizarre bent) occasionally finds the obscure haunt that makes you think, hey, good idea, I'll visit there on my next trip. In Florence, Rosenthal visited no less than three places--the lampredotto stand near the Ponte Vecchio, Vivoli for gelato, and a pilgrimage to see Dario Cecchini the butcher in Panzano-in-Chianti--that have been showcased multiple times on food/travel shows before. I think the clip that Phil had with Dario reciting Italian poetry at the dinner table was almost verbatim from a Bourdain episode a few years back.
Still...I can't look away. The freaking camerawork is that good. Hong Kong is next.
P.S. From a cooking standpoint, I've learned quite a bit from David Rocco's shows. Simple, quick, and he stresses quality ingredients.
Last edited by
jnm123 on October 13th, 2015, 1:43 pm, edited 1 time in total.