I have recently signed up for HelloFresh after researching a few of the other options like Plated and Blue Apron. After 3 weeks I can say we have been very happy with the quality, convenience, packaging and most of all taste of the meals.
Hello fresh packages each meal within in its own box, and each protein individually wrapped (and placed on/near the ice). So for a weekly box with 3 meals, the delivered box will contain 3 small boxes inside, and 3 proteins. If multiple recipes require the same produce, spice, vinegar, milk, etc. there will be a separate one packaged in each individual meal box. Unlike Blue Apron, where you have to be aware if more than one recipe calls for the same item, HelloFresh removes this issue. Salt, Pepper and Oil are the only ingredients you need to provide yourself. All other spices, vinegars, soup bases, milk, cream, etc are included in the kits.
For anyone with slightly above novice kitchen skills, the recipes are broken down pretty well and written with easily followed instructions. Always good to read the whole recipe thru first, so all components complete at the same time and you are not waiting for the potatoes to finish while your chicken entree gets cold. A true novice may struggle a little at first with amount ambiguities in the recipes, like "season with salt and pepper", or add a drizzle of oil to the pan, etc. Also, pot/pan sizes can make a difference if you are un-aware that a larger pan will mean a sauce will reduce quicker. For example, instructions for Jasmine Rice called for 1 cup of water to cook the quantity of rice provided, but because of larger pot size, or higher heat, the water was absorbed/evaporated well before the rice was done/tender. Easily resolved by adding a little more water until it was done, but following the recipe card to the letter of the law would have yielded undercooked, crunchy or burned rice. Each recipe on average takes 15-30 minutes from start to finish.
The quality of the ingredients has been high. The only issue encountered so far in all the kits was an avocado that was too hard to make the guacamole that the recipe included. If I had opened the box a day or so earlier and checked, it would have been fine. Each week there is a choice of meals. Options include at least one beef, chicken, fish/seafood, pork and vegetarian dish to choose from. It's easy to chose your meals for each week, and you can see the menu and pick about a month in advance. You can skip weeks whenever you want and cancel at any time.
Overall I give very high marks to HelloFresh. It's super convenient, reasonably priced, tasty and most of all allows me to cook fresh, portion controlled meals during the week without having to worry about shopping, etc.